210c Pine Ave, Anna Maria, FL 34216
The quickly crowned donut king of the island, The Donut Experiment opened in 2012 and is already a franchised establishment. Stop in for a custom box of divine cake donuts garnished with whatever heavenly toppings you choose and oh-so instaworthy!
3900 E Bay Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217
Publix is the East Coast grocery chain of choice, they pride themselves with fresh ingredients and a home made approach to baking-so they’re donuts are a must try! They make both types of donuts or you can pick up donut holes for a group, we personally suggest trying them and coming back for lunch to try one of their glorious sub sandwiches.
9807 Gulf Dr, Anna Maria, FL 34216
While you can’t get a donut here you can get a Cinnamon Bun the size of your head! This island staple offers up some of the most scrumptiously over-sized treats on the island so if you also consider cinnabuns to be donut adjacent stop by and browse their eclectic artsy gift store while wait!
3302 E Bay Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217
Not an “island exclusive” but they still make a great frosted donut and now that Dunkin’ Donuts has restructured their menus to a curtailed version of select donuts the freshness is sure to increase, try the “new” dunkin’ donuts menu at it’s new island location in Holmes Beach!